Heads up: Some or all of the identifications affected by this split may have been replaced with identifications of Neotamias. This happens when we can't automatically assign an identification to one of the output taxa. Review identifications of Neotamias durangae 520584

Taxonomic Split 78353 (Tehty 10-09-2021)

Ramírez-Pulido, José, et al. "List of recent land mammals of Mexico." (2014). --

"Thorington and Hoffmann (2005) treated Neotamias durangae solivagus as a synonym of N. durangae durangae; nevertheless, and contrary to their usage, we treat solivagus as a species for the following reasons: 1) the morphological analysis by Levenson et al. (1985) showed that solivagus is different from, and on a linage apart from, durangae; 2) Piaggio and Spicer (2001), analyzed cytochrome oxidase subunit II and cytochrome b for specimens they identified as bulleri (= solivagus, because the sample came from Coahuila), and showed in all of their cladograms that durangae was basal to and clearly separate from their “N. bulleri solivagus”; 3) N. solivagus differs from N. durangae and N. bulleri, especially in color pattern and bacular morphology (Callahan 1980; Bartig et al. 1993; Best et al. 1993); and 4) solivagus is geographically isolated from both N. bulleri and N. durangae, and, in fact, is found in a different biogeographic region. N. solivagus is in the Sierra Madre Oriental, and N. bulleri and N. durangae occur in the Sierra Madre Occidental with the Mexican Plateau, a broad geographic barrier, separating them."

tuntematon
Lisännyt jwidness kesäkuu 18, 2020 01:13 IP. | Tallentanut bobby23 syyskuu 10, 2021
jakaa

Kommentit

Taxon change requested here: https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/49875362

MDD doesn't currently recognize this species, but intends to do so in the next release. I'm not sure if we've made a decision about whether to wait for the release or go ahead? @bobby23

Lähettänyt jwidness melkein 4 vuotta sitten

I agree that there is sufficiente support to consider Neotamias durangae solivagus as a distinct spacies: Neotamias solivagus.

Lähettänyt marcelo_aranda melkein 4 vuotta sitten

Also the book "Keys for identifying Mexican mammals" by Alvarez-Castañeda, ST et al., 2017, Johns Hopkins Univ Press, recognizes as separate species Neotamias solivagus and Neotamias durangae, page 390, N. solivagus endemic from Coahuila and Nuevo León, clarifying, to date there is no published record of any locality in Nuevo León, only two localities, the Sierra de La Concordia as a type locality and the Sierra de San Antonio de Las Alazana in Arteaga, both in Coahuila.

Lähettänyt davidmercado melkein 4 vuotta sitten

Personally, if the change will be reflected in the next version of the MDD, and members of the iNaturalist user-base request it, I think integrating the specified taxon is fine.

If it were a species recently described under questionable methodology, or a species not widely accepted, I would hold reservations. But this is fine to me.

However, I believe @loarie has reservations about this type of integration and would rather we follow MDD as currently available. I encourage him to chime in. I also believe Jakob is of the opinion that we should stick to whatever authority we chose for mammals and keep deviations to a minimum.

Lähettänyt bobby23 melkein 4 vuotta sitten

@loarie
@jwidness

The American Mammalogist Association already considers Neotamias solivagus as a species of its own

https://www.mammaldiversity.org/explore.html

The Mammal Diversity Database of the American Society of Mammalogists (ASM) is your home base for tracking the latest taxonomic changes to living and recently extinct (i.e., since ~1500 CE) species and higher taxa of mammals.

Species ID Genus Species Family Order
1001757 Neotamias solivagus Sciuridae Rodentia

and this paper accepts the species Neotamias solivagus

http://mastozoologiamexicana.com/ojs/index.php/theryanotes/article/view/71/48

http://mastozoologiamexicana.com/ojs/index.php/theryanotes/article/view/71

Lähettänyt davidmercado yli 2 vuotta sitten

I think it is already possible to activate this species ( Neotamias solivagus )

Lähettänyt davidmercado yli 2 vuotta sitten

Lisää kommentti

Kirjaudu sisään tai Rekisteröidy lisätäksesi kommentteja